Unofficial fan site · not affiliated with Amazon MGM Studios / Prime Video or the show's producers · how we work

ConfirmedUpdated Nov 16, 2026 · 28 sources

Theo's Season 3 Twist, the Nazgul Theory, and Major Character Deaths

Season 3 has delivered major turning points, most notably Theo's alliance with Sauron, the reveal of his father's identity, and multiple major character deaths through Episode 4. While actor Tyroe Muhafidin calls this the pinnacle of Theo's journey and notes that fans nailed a key theory about the character, community debates are divided over whether making Theo a Ringwraith or the Witch-king makes narrative sense.

Theo's Transformation and the Nazgul Debate

Season 3 marks a dark turn for Theo, featuring an alliance with Sauron, a Season 3 murder, and a major twist by the end of Episode 4. In interviews with UPI and BuzzFeed, actor Tyroe Muhafidin described Season 3 as the pinnacle of Theo's journey. Speaking to Decider, Muhafidin explained the character's shocking murder by noting that Theo is angry at the world, and he told People.com that he hopes fans do not hate him after the twist. He also mentioned to TV Insider that fans nailed it with their theory about Theo.

On Reddit's r/ringsofpower, fan discussion has zeroed in on what receiving a Ring of Power means for Theo's future, including a fan theory questioning whether Theo is the Witch-king and whether the ring will strip him of his humanity. However, other fans on r/ringsofpower have criticized the plot decision, arguing that while Sauron is busy turning great and powerful men into his Nazgul servants to amass armies, it makes little sense for him to give a ring to an unknown village kid with no title, army, or influence.

The Mystery of Theo's Father

Another major Season 3 development is the revealed identity of Theo's father, which GamesRadar+ reports is a sign of dark things to come. However, Tyroe Muhafidin teased to GamesRadar+ that there may still be more to the father reveal than what viewers have seen so far.

Fans on r/ringsofpower are actively debating whether the father reveal in Episode 2 can be trusted at face value. One fan discussion points out that an analysis of Episode 2 suggested Sauron might have lied to Theo about his father as a form of manipulation. Another Reddit post questions whether Theo and Sauron are simply lying to each other, noting that Theo actually found the sword in Waldreg's barn rather than getting it from his father.

Major Season 3 Character Deaths Through Episode 4

Alongside Theo's transformation, the first four episodes of Season 3 have featured multiple character deaths, including an opening death, a death in Episode 2, and an off-screen death of a major Tolkien character reported by TVLine. Episode 4 also killed off a main character, with a star of the show telling Reactor Magazine that Season 3 just had its own Red Wedding. According to The Direct, one star revealed what was going through their head when they killed one of the show's mainstay original characters, while another report noted Episode 4's death cut short a potential top-tier friendship.

Cast members have spoken extensively with outlets about the fallout of these exits, with stars telling IGN that the two big Season 3 deaths were the correct, if painful, end of their journeys. Tyroe Muhafidin told GamesRadar+ that it took him a while to get over Episode 4's big death. Meanwhile, actor Ismael Cruz Cordova has addressed Arondir's emotional Season 3 arc and whether the character is really gone in interviews with Yahoo, Collider, and TV Insider, while ScreenRant noted the show also killed off its version of Samwise Gamgee.

Two sides of the debate

Theo's Dark Turn Works Well

  • Actor Tyroe Muhafidin views this dark evolution as the pinnacle of Theo's journey and noted that fans nailed their theory about the character.
  • Theo's anger at the world and Sauron's manipulation regarding his father set up a compelling path where the ring could strip him of his humanity and turn him into the Witch-king.

The Plot Twist Has Flaws

  • Fans on Reddit argue it makes no sense for Sauron to give a Ring of Power to an unknown village kid with no title, army, or influence when he is supposed to be recruiting powerful men.
  • The father reveal in Episode 2 has inconsistencies, as Reddit users pointed out Theo found the sword in Waldreg's barn rather than getting it from his dad, suggesting he and Sauron are lying to each other.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: What do you think of Theo receiving a Ring of Power and aligning with Sauron in Season 3?

Vote to see what other fans think.

Do you think Sauron told Theo the truth about his father, or is it a manipulation tactic that will backfire?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from Rings of Power S3